by Steve ‘DDT’ Giannopoulos
As promised, here is the decklist:
The point of burn decks in general is to get the opponent from 20 to 0 as quickly as possible. The strategy is usually restricted to mono red decks but Wizards of the Coast usually test the boundaries on how quickly you can burn someone down. With cards like Boros Charm and Bump in the Night, we have to splash a couple of colors to get the job done more quickly now. Seeing as how we have 2 sets of ‘duals’ for each color combination right now, it seemed like a good time to try it.
The deck is 3 colors but technically Deathrite Shaman is also green and we sometimes want to make use of the green ability to gain some life in a damage race. Keep in mind that you probably want to keep the black mana producing lands unused in order to further burn your opponent at end of turn as opposed to keeping Stomping Grounds untapped (unless you really have to).
This is the ideal damage output series of plays:
… or something along those lines. 20 uninterrupted points of damage without counting on any guaranteed attack
Of course this is just the ideal. You can also just win on later turns. The deck does pack some Skullcracks to deal with the Thragtusk life gaining. The Deathrite Shamans almost double your burn value as well so if you get into the mid-game you can still hope to win. The rest of the deck is very similar to your basic burn/aggro deck.
He does good work, despite not being a red card
In Testing …
I went to a few local FNM’s and other tournaments with this build. It was fun winning a few games in 5 turns or so without ever having to interact with my opponent’s board except for casting a Skullcrack in response to a Thragtusk. This deck is a fine deck for any smoker, unfortunately I am not a nicotine addict.
It did really well versus established decks but fell short against the randomest of random decks. At one point, I actually managed to -4 my Tibalt and hit my opponent for 6 damage! I don’t know if most of you are aware of how much of an achievement this this. It’s a creature dominated format after all, so keeping Tibalt alive is rather tough (activating his ultimate is rather impossible). Unfortunately, he ended at 1 life (Tibalt would have hot for 7 damage, had he not flashed a Restoration Angel in response). It was almost as if he knew that 1 point of damage mattered. Still, running a Tibalt somewhat successfully got the deck noticed.
The other, other, other….other Planeswalker
The overall win percentage was about 55%, which means I’ll be looking for something else to run at the World Magic Cup Qualifier.
Are you qualified?
Another problem was that a lot of people were playing decks like Naya Blitz, Red Green Aggor, Hexproof Bant and Black White Zombies. In these kinds of matchups, it becomes a war of attrition. Basically, the last random dude standing that gets to attack is probably going to win. Considering that 8 of my main deck burn cards cannot target creatured, I’m not going to win that attrition war.
You basically get to punish a lot, I mean a lot of midrange decks. They usually take a bit of shockland damage or are slow enough out of the gate for you to take advantage. Also, versus control, you can technically ‘overcommit’ on weenies if you are holding a Boros Charm for their Supreme Verdict.
I think I was overall really disappointed with the ‘fourth’ color (aka. Green). Eventhough I never ended up facing any Reanimator strategies, I felt that splashing for that was really weak. It seemed really nice, cool and techy in the beginning. Cutting the Green altogether would change the manabase quite a bit. The Shaman would stay as he does a great impression of Grim Lavamancer in this deck.
Oh, how this card is missed!
A card that I was unsure about playing is Brimstone Volley. After testing, I would definitely try 2 in a more refined build. Casting a late game Vexing Devil hoping they take 4 so that you can pay 3 mana to hit them for what should be the final 5 points of damage is really ambitious.
Not too shabby
Blind Obedience was obviously hard to evaluate with only one copy in the whole deck. If I recall correctly, it was rather good when I got it in play. Each burn doing one extra is really nice and I would eventually fit in a second copy into the deck. If it does more than 3 life loss, it was already been better than Bump in the Night. Then again, at that point in the game, Bump in the Night would have done 6 (assuming you had mana to flash it back).
The bonus of having your opponents would be blockers enter the battlefield tapped is nice when you’re attacking with little dudes trying to go through medium to big creatures. The Black/White ‘kicker’ to your burn spells is just gravy. Red being your main color, means you will probably have extra black or white mana to Extort your opponent. Also, it’s nice seeing an enchantment that doesn’t become useless when you put a second one in play.
Did he pass the test?
The Zombie of the Hour! How did he fare? Well, for one, against anything running small removal spells (Aristocrats, RG Aggro, etc) he was basically a lightning rod. He did a decent job against slower decks by helping out with aggro a bit. In the end, he just seemed to be lacking a little something. Perhaps in a future version with Lotleth Troll as a discard outlet? Who knows?
The problem that you first notice is when you are ‘flooded’. I do not even mean realistically flooded, just for this deck. Flooded is anything over 4 mana, unless you are planning on flashing back a Bump in the Night for the final bits of damage. I think the Troll would fill this role nicely, since he provides great aggro and has trample so he doesn’t get token-chumped.
The future of 4 color burn?
Getting back to the Blood Scrivener: multiple copies stack, which is great when you’re empty handed. Furthermore, with this deck we can just throw our last burn spell in hand at our opponent before our draw phase to get some more draws. Scrivener was no Dark Confidant, but then again what really is? He performed above average in most of my games, but nothing made me really go Wow! i don’t think he currently is awesome enough to play a Red/Black/x burn deck at the moment, but give it time. We have a whole new block coming in November and not a lot of these cards are rotating (Bump, Searing Spear, Pillar of Flame and some lands)
The best upside to Scrivener was the ability to mulligan a bit more aggressively versus certain decks. Knowing you are facing a slower deck allows you to maybe even keep a reasonable 5 card opener with Blood Scrivener. I’m not saying it’s Insane! but it’s something worth considering.
What now ?
I will personally keep an eye out for any other interesting Blood Scrivener deck posibilities (including Duskmantle Seer deck possibilities). Core Set M14 might bring something to the table. As of right now it offers:
Gives more value to your burn and allows you to recover from a board whipe
Instant speed Pillar of Flame is back!
Still, there’s about 100 cards left to be spoiled. We can always hope.
If anyone has other suggestions on improving, tweaking or taking the deck in a whole new direction (other than the trash), please reply in the blog or hit us up on our Facebook page .